(Bloomberg)--Senate Republicans clashed Sunday about the path forward for their stalled healthcare bill, with passage of any plan before the August congressional recess in doubt and rival factions trying to pull it in opposite directions.

Senator Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, speaking on “Fox News Sunday,” declared an earlier Republican leadership plan “dead” and suggested turning to a different bill that he drafted with Republican Senator Susan Collins of Maine. He put the odds of passing a bill in July at “50-50.”

While some conservatives and President Donald Trump have suggested repealing President Barack Obama’s Affordable Care Act and replacing it later in a separate measure if the party can’t pass a combined bill, Cassidy called the idea “a nonstarter” that would raise premiums and betray Trump’s campaign promises.

Senator Ted Cruz of Texas, a leader of the conservative faction in the chamber, separately pitched his proposal to allow insurers to offer insurance plans that are cheaper with less coverage, as long as they also offer a plans complying with the Affordable Care Act’s mandates.

Critics have said that approach will result in higher premiums for older and sicker Americans, including those with chronic, pre-existing conditions, as younger, healthier people choose more basic plans. But Cruz said it would give millions of people more affordable choices, and that taxpayers would subsidize sicker people with money already in the bill for plans in health-insurance exchanges.

Cassidy said he’d have to see the legislative language for Cruz’s proposal but that it would be bad for older, sicker people to be separated into their own pool for insurance coverage. Republican Senator Chuck Grassley of Iowa previously told Iowa Public Radio that he’d oppose the measure if it undermined protections for pre-existing health conditions.

Cassidy’s bill with Collins would keep most of the Affordable Care Act’s taxes to pay for a more robust replacement. He said that’s “the only path forward” that would enable Republicans to keep Trump’s campaign promises such as protecting people with pre-existing conditions while eliminating Obamacare’s insurance mandates.

But Cruz said consumers should also have the ability to buy cheaper plans with less coverage, and that many people simply can’t afford plans under Obamacare.

“You, the consumer, should be able to choose what healthcare you want to buy,” Cruz said on ABC’s “This Week.” He added that it’s “wildly unfair” for younger people to subsidize older, sicker people and said taxes, not mandates, should pay for that.

The Trump administration is taking a more optimistic view on passing a bill. The Senate may delay its August recess to finish the healthcare overhaul, White House Chief of Staff Reince Priebus predicted on “Fox News Sunday.”

Priebus said the Senate “will get a repeal and replace” bill passed either before or “during” the August recess, and that senators are putting together their wish lists for the measure.

“I don’t believe it’s in half as much trouble as the media wants it to be in,” Priebus said of the healthcare measure crafted by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and a small number of Republican lawmakers.

Trump took to Twitter on Sunday to once again cajole wavering Republicans to act. “For years, even as a ‘civilian,’ I listened as Republicans pushed the Repeal and Replace of ObamaCare. Now they finally have their chance!”

Asked whether a bill will come to the floor for a vote before the August recess, Republican Senator John Barrasso of Wyoming said, “Absolutely, we need to do it.”

“There’s an urgency to getting it done for the American people because Obamacare is so unstable,” Barrasso said on Fox News Channel’s “Sunday Morning Futures.”

Barrasso said expansion of Medicaid under Obamacare made the joint federal-state health-insurance program that covers millions of poor and elderly people a “dumping ground” for able-bodied adults.

That’s a different view, however, from Republican senators such as Dean Heller of Nevada, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Rob Portman of Ohio. They’ve insisted on protecting people who gained insurance through that expansion in their states.

McConnell last week left open the possibility that Republicans won’t be able to reach a deal, saying a bipartisan fix to stabilize the insurance market would still be needed if that happens.

Senator John McCain of Arizona said on CBS’s “Face the Nation” that he thinks the leadership’s bill is “probably going to be dead.” He blamed a partisan approach similar to how the Affordable Care Act was originally passed in 2010 by Democrats without any Republican votes.

Register or login for access to this item and much more

All Health Data Management content is archived after seven days.

Community members receive:
  • All recent and archived articles
  • Conference offers and updates
  • A full menu of enewsletter options
  • Web seminars, white papers, ebooks

Don't have an account? Register for Free Unlimited Access